I would have liked this book a lot more if it was only Echo's story and there was no relationship with Noah. I didn't like him at all and the only reason I kept reading was because I was interested in Echo's past and her relationship with her family and how things would turn out with them. Echo annoyed me and there were issues with her plot (also it took me like, half the book to even become vaguely interested in her. ESPECIALLY in the first part of the book, so much teenage angst) but it was way better than Noah's.